4
Executive Summary and Recommendations
Despite the progress made on women’s rights in the last decade, the situation of women in
Afghanistan remains dire. There is a need for significant change in the attitudes and
behaviors of Afghan men towards women. Characterized by parochialism, suspicion,
violence and control, Afghan men largely view women as subordinates and often treat them
either with denigration or negligence. The entrenched attitudes and behaviors of Afghan
men are central to understanding the slow pace of Afghan women’s development.
In order for women to continue their progress in social, economic, political and private
spheres, attitudinal changes in Afghan men are essential to creating a favorable institutional
and social environment for this to occur.
Afghan men dominate key institutions and social structures that not only influence, but also
shape and configure, women’s life in public and private realms. Patriarchal family structures,
a masculine religious establishment, unsafe public space, the male dominated market place
and conservative culture and traditions considerably restrain women both privately and
publicly. Women face complex structural forces that tacitly and expressly affect their lives
and negatively impact their ability to change their situation.
Religious forces have a long historical record of suppressing women with strict and inflexible
religious interpretation. Religious establishments in various forms - madrasas, mosques and
other localized centers of learning and counseling - have structured and sustained a deeply
conservative discourse on women that constrains them. What social functions women have,
how they should live their life, and how they should appear in public and in private, are
predominantly defined by the interpretations of these religious institutions, actors and
practices.
Engagement and interactions with mullahs throughout our research revealed that they could
be loosely divided into two broad camps with certain variations according to their views on
women: the extremist and the moderate.
The extremist mullahs that wield significant sway are immersed in the communities and
operate independently of any form of governmental and civil society oversight, rejecting
women’s role outside the family environment by considering it against Islamic Sharia codes.
They promote a puritanical view of women advocating strict gender segregation and the
veiling of women. They promote their extremist reading of women’s social role with
inflammatory and religiously charged orations and speeches using their extended network of
mosques, families, friends and communities. In their view, Afghan women’s ethical integrity
has been harmed in the wake of the Taliban’s fall and this trend must be reversed.
The moderate mullahs allow women a role in the public realm but urge their strict
compliance with the Islamic code of dress and behavior. They express concerns about the